Constitutional Perspectives

Table of Contents

The Nature of the Union, Part II: The Compact Theory

On November 6th, 1860, Abraham Lincoln was elected President of the United States. The first Republican to win the office – only six years after the party was formed! – Lincoln won exclusively with the votes of Northern states (plus a few newly-admitted states on the Pacific coast). Indeed, Lincoln did not receive a single popular vote in any state south of Virginia. It was not hard to see why the South had such antipathy for the new president: the Republican Party was genuinely opposed to the "peculiar institution" of chattel slavery. Not, to be sure, as ardently opposed as Southerners feared: Lincoln was a lawyer, of quite a conservative disposition in many ways. He knew, he would tell anyone who asked, that the Constitution provided no power by which the federal government could abolish slavery. At most it could arrest its spread.

The South cared little for such nuance. By February 1861, seven states – all in the Deep South – had seceded from the Union. (Well, purported to, anyway.) On February 4th, these states joined together to form the Confederate States of America. Lincoln took office as president, and began to take actions opposing secession (as his predecessor James Buchanan had conspicuously failed to do). These actions led to the Battle of Fort Sumter on April 12th, after which four more states, notably including Virginia, seceded as well, and the Civil War was officially underway.

It should come as no surprise that South Carolina was the first state to secede. A convention met on December 17th, just six weeks after Lincoln's election. Three days later, the convention voted to secede; a declaration of the causes of secession followed on the 24th. It is this document that interests us. Much of its text is devoted to the specific grievances motivation South Carolina to leave the Union, the supposed betrayal by the Northern states. The beginning, however, explains the theory on which it had the right to leave. It is worth printing this passage in full:

The people of the State of South Carolina, in Convention assembled, on the 26th day of April, A.D., 1852, declared that the frequent violations of the Constitution of the United States, by the Federal Government, and its encroachments upon the reserved rights of the States, fully justified this State in then withdrawing from the Federal Union; but in deference to the opinions and wishes of the other slaveholding States, she forbore at that time to exercise this right. Since that time, these encroachments have continued to increase, and further forbearance ceases to be a virtue.

And now the State of South Carolina having resumed her separate and equal place among nations, deems it due to herself, to the remaining United States of America, and to the nations of the world, that she should declare the immediate causes which have led to this act.

In the year 1765, that portion of the British Empire embracing Great Britain, undertook to make laws for the government of that portion composed of the thirteen American Colonies. A struggle for the right of self-government ensued, which resulted, on the 4th of July, 1776, in a Declaration, by the Colonies, "that they are, and of right ought to be, FREE AND INDEPENDENT STATES; and that, as free and independent States, they have full power to levy war, conclude peace, contract alliances, establish commerce, and to do all other acts and things which independent States may of right do."

They further solemnly declared that whenever any "form of government becomes destructive of the ends for which it was established, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute a new government." Deeming the Government of Great Britain to have become destructive of these ends, they declared that the Colonies "are absolved from all allegiance to the British Crown, and that all political connection between them and the State of Great Britain is, and ought to be, totally dissolved."

In pursuance of this Declaration of Independence, each of the thirteen States proceeded to exercise its separate sovereignty; adopted for itself a Constitution, and appointed officers for the administration of government in all its departments– Legislative, Executive and Judicial. For purposes of defense, they united their arms and their counsels; and, in 1778, they entered into a League known as the Articles of Confederation, whereby they agreed to entrust the administration of their external relations to a common agent, known as the Congress of the United States, expressly declaring, in the first Article "that each State retains its sovereignty, freedom and independence, and every power, jurisdiction and right which is not, by this Confederation, expressly delegated to the United States in Congress assembled."

Under this Confederation the war of the Revolution was carried on, and on the 3rd of September, 1783, the contest ended, and a definite Treaty was signed by Great Britain, in which she acknowledged the independence of the Colonies in the following terms: "ARTICLE 1– His Britannic Majesty acknowledges the said United States, viz: New Hampshire, Massachusetts Bay, Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina and Georgia, to be FREE, SOVEREIGN AND INDEPENDENT STATES; that he treats with them as such; and for himself, his heirs and successors, relinquishes all claims to the government, propriety and territorial rights of the same and every part thereof."

Thus were established the two great principles asserted by the Colonies, namely: the right of a State to govern itself; and the right of a people to abolish a Government when it becomes destructive of the ends for which it was instituted. And concurrent with the establishment of these principles, was the fact, that each Colony became and was recognized by the mother Country a FREE, SOVEREIGN AND INDEPENDENT STATE.

In 1787, Deputies were appointed by the States to revise the Articles of Confederation, and on 17th September, 1787, these Deputies recommended for the adoption of the States, the Articles of Union, known as the Constitution of the United States.

The parties to whom this Constitution was submitted, were the several sovereign States; they were to agree or disagree, and when nine of them agreed the compact was to take effect among those concurring; and the General Government, as the common agent, was then invested with their authority.

If only nine of the thirteen States had concurred, the other four would have remained as they then were– separate, sovereign States, independent of any of the provisions of the Constitution. In fact, two of the States did not accede to the Constitution until long after it had gone into operation among the other eleven; and during that interval, they each exercised the functions of an independent nation.

By this Constitution, certain duties were imposed upon the several States, and the exercise of certain of their powers was restrained, which necessarily implied their continued existence as sovereign States. But to remove all doubt, an amendment was added, which declared that the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States, respectively, or to the people. On the 23d May , 1788, South Carolina, by a Convention of her People, passed an Ordinance assenting to this Constitution, and afterwards altered her own Constitution, to conform herself to the obligations she had undertaken.

Thus was established, by compact between the States, a Government with definite objects and powers, limited to the express words of the grant. This limitation left the whole remaining mass of power subject to the clause reserving it to the States or to the people, and rendered unnecessary any specification of reserved rights.

We hold that the Government thus established is subject to the two great principles asserted in the Declaration of Independence; and we hold further, that the mode of its formation subjects it to a third fundamental principle, namely: the law of compact. We maintain that in every compact between two or more parties, the obligation is mutual; that the failure of one of the contracting parties to perform a material part of the agreement, entirely releases the obligation of the other; and that where no arbiter is provided, each party is remitted to his own judgment to determine the fact of failure, with all its consequences.

In the present case, that fact is established with certainty. We assert that fourteen of the States have deliberately refused, for years past, to fulfill their constitutional obligations, and we refer to their own Statutes for the proof.

The highlighted portion is the essence of the Compact Theory: that the Constitution of 1787 was created by the states. The rest of the passage contains a series of arguments, concerning the sequence of events from before independence through to ratification, supporting this claim.

Perhaps the most important is this: that through the Declaration of Independence, the thirteen colonies of British North America became thirteen independent states – independent nations, we might say, for that is what the word "state" meant prior to its usage in American federalism. The treaties of Westphalia, which had ended the Thirty Years' War in 1648, gave rise to a system of state sovereignty, following the theories of the jurists Bodin and Grotius. When the Declaration says that the Colonies "are, and ... ought to be, Free and Independent States," then, this is what it means: that each colony ought to be its own sovereign political entity, of the same rank with, say, the kingdom of France. This is confirmed, moreover, in that the Declaration repeatedly uses plural language when speaking of the states, saying "they" and "them" throughout.

This sovereign independence, moreover, was not only declared but achieved: we won the War for Independence, as Britain had to acknowledge in the 1783 Treaty of Paris. This treaty, again, spoke of the thirteen colonies – now states – as a plurality of separate entities. King George agreed to treat with "them" as independent states, creating diplomatic relations not with a single country but with thirteen.

Now in the meanwhile the thirteen colonies – states, by their own reckoning, if not yet in the King's – had united to form common government institutions. These, as South Carolina would have it, did not in any way alter their status as independent nations. Each state had, immediately upon declaring independence in 1776, organized its own political affairs, and had done so as a purely internal matter. Yes, the states had joined together in the Continental Congress. But it was hardly unknown for sovereign nations to join together for purposes of mutual defense.

The Articles of Confederation was expressly a compact for just such a league of sovereign states: as the secession declaration notes, it declared right at the outset that each state retained its "sovereignty, freedom, and independence." The Articles conferred certain powers on Congress, and imposed certain duties on the states. But sovereign, independent entities are always free to covenant with others of their kind. When individual humans do this with one another, we call the resulting covenant a contract. And the Articles were just another contract. The states had agreed to certain terms, and were bound by that promise. This was the exercise of their independent sovereignty, not the negation thereof.

We come, then, to the formation of the Constitution in 1787. This did not, South Carolina avers, in any way modify the "two great principles" of the Declaration: that the states were independent, and that they had the right of self-government. Moreover, the "mode of its formation" confirms that, like the Articles, the Constitution was a contract among the states, subject to the "law of compact." The delegates to the Philadelphia Convention, after all, had been charged – by the states – with amending the Articles of Confederation. And their work product was submitted to the states for ratification. It took effect only among those states that agreed to the terms; two states – North Carolina and Rhode Island – did not ratify until after the Constitution had already gone into effect. They could have simply remained separate, independent as they had been from July 4th, 1776. Whatever "union" existed among the states did not in any way give the majority a power to compel these holdouts.

Hence the doctrine of secession. It is not quite that each state was free to quit the compact at its liberty. Contracts and covenants are binding upon those who make them, and South Carolina acknowledged as much. But they do not subsume the sovereignty of the contracting parties; that would be absurd. And they do not bind forever and in all cases. Specifically, where one party to a contract is not meeting its obligations, the other party may therefore be released from its obligations. This had been the theory on which the states abandoned the Articles: its terms were not being upheld, and this gave each state the right to exit the compact and form another. South Carolina was just doing the exact same thing, because the North had not honored its end of the bargain (particularly concerning the return of fugitive slaves). No tribunal had been provided to determine whether or not the states were meeting their obligations under the Constitution, so every state the right to judge for itself – indeed, had to judge for itself.

Note, by the way, the little cameo of Jefferson's philosophy of strict construction. South Carolina notes that the Constitution "established ... a government with definite objects and powers, limited to the express words of the grant." Jefferson inferred the doctrine of strict construction from something like this same view of the Union, and counsel for Maryland had argued the same in McCulloch. Here we see the inference running the other way. Because the Constitution is organized on principles of strict construction, because under the Tenth Amendment the great residuum of government power was reserved to the states, we can see that the states retain their sovereignty. The very fact that the Constitution imposed some limits on state power, imposed some duties on the states, only highlights that they retained their sovereign character: for otherwise there would be nothing to limit or oblige.

I am not here going to catalogue every single error in the Compact Theory. Some of those should already be apparent to the keen reader; the bulk will have to wait for later in this module. But I do want to note a couple things right now, beginning with the way South Carolina reads the Declaration of Independence. Compact theory takes more or less for granted that, when the Declaration speaks of the (former) colonies as "Free and Independent States," it necessarily means independent of one another. But of course the main point of the Declaration was their independence from Great Britain. This language, then, is not necessarily inconsistent with the view that the newly independent states were in fact bound together in a single nation.

Granted, that nation has a kind of plural character to it, hence the use of "they" and "them." But this does not necessarily answer the question. The same is true of King George's acknowledgement of the newly independent states in the Treaty of Paris. Saying that he would treat with "them" as free and independent states did not necessarily imply treating them as thirteen separate sovereignties, rather than a single sovereignty made up of thirteen states. Indeed, under the Articles of Confederation, George would not have "treated" with the states individually; Article IX gave Congress the "sole and exclusive right" of "sending and receiving ambassadors," and of "entering into treaties and alliances." Jefferson, as Minister to France from 1785 to 1789, represented the United States, not Virginia.

Now this is not enough to say that the Compact Doctrine is wrong. That, again, will await future lessons. For the time being it is enough to show that it makes rather too much of the evidence, which is more ambiguous than the compact theorists would allow.

Logo design by Alexandra Gallant-Lee

Animated banner by Victoria Gualtieri

Copyright 2026 Constitutional Innovation Center