Constitutional Perspectives

Table of Contents

Constitutional Perspectives

Welcome to Constitutional Perspectives, a series of explanatory essays about the United States Constitution and the system of government it creates!

First launched in June 2025 under the auspices of The Evening Constitutional, the series is now an official publication of the Constitutional Innovation Center. It is intended as an educational resource for the public, because we cannot reform our constitutional system if we do not first understand it.

The title of the series is meant to capture several different qualities. First, this is my perspective on constitutional law. Not that I don’t discuss the different sides of controverted questions, but I do not aspire to any kind of overall neutrality. My goal is to explain the Constitution as best I can, according to my own understanding thereof.

Second, it is meant to capture the fractal quality of the project. What do I mean by this? The defining qualities of fractals, the geometric entities, is self-similarity. Picture, say, the Sierpinski gasket. If you zoom in on any smaller triangle, you find that it's identical to the larger structure. That pattern just repeats in miniature, all the way down. The same is true for, say, the Mandelbrot set: if you zoom in far enough, you find tiny little Mandelbrot sets hiding in the picture, and if you zoom in far enough on those you find more of them, and so on.
Law is like this. Every answer spawns new questions, at a greater level of granularity. Those smaller questions are every bit as complex and thorny as the bigger ones, and the arguments they generate can be every bit as heated. You can always go deeper; there is no such thing as "knowing all the law" in perfect detail.

But there's a curious corollary, especially I think as to constitutional law. The Sierpinski gasket, and many other similar fractals, have the strange property that it has finite surface area but an infinitely long perimeter. The proof of the first part is simple: you can draw a square around the gasket, the square has finite area, and the gasket necessarily has an area no greater than that. Similarly, although it is not possible to know the law in perfect detail, it is possible to have a grasp of the entire field of constitutional law if you're only worried about the broad contours.

Inspired by this quality of “fractal complexity,” Constitutional Perspectives is organized into levels. Each level aspires to provide a comprehensive picture of the Constitution; the higher levels will provide that picture in greater detail. Level One provides a basic overview of the constitutional system. The premise of Level One is that it should be accessible to someone who has no prior knowledge of American constitutional law or history.

You can think of this as a “high school civics” perspective, although of course it will be high school civics as seen through the eyes of a constitutional theorist. Partly owing to that distinctive flavor, although Level One does not require any prior knowledge of the subject, it is not meant to be trivial for the more advanced reader, either. It will offer a particular way of looking at the very basics of our system of government, a distinct perspective, you might say. And it is always useful to bear these essential aspects of the constitutional structure in mind, even when doing constitutional law at a much higher level.

Level Two, then, is pitched at something more like the level of an introductory law school course on constitutional law. One key difference from Level One is that Level Two begins to explore the world of decisional law, i.e. leading precedents of the Supreme Court (and other important government actors). Another difference is that Level Two is broken up into several different modules, each considering a particular topic at some length. These topics are what I think of as the Big Questions, the deepest and most important questions about how to understand the Constitution and live under it in practice. The first module, for example, is addressed to the question of the implied powers of Congress, and the great case of McCulloch v. Maryland. The second module will address the great debate over the nature of the Union. These were defining conflicts of the early American Republic and the antebellum period. In my view, it is through understanding these foundational questions that we come to understand the Constitution itself, and develop a strong theoretical foundation with which to approach the issues that are heavily contested in our own time. Other modules will address the big questions about presidential and judicial power, individual rights and the law of equality, as well as introducing the reader to the essentials of constitutional interpretation and a bit of legal theory.

Finally, Level Three will explore specific topics in greater detail, more akin to a law school seminar than to a survey course. Comprehensiveness at this level is more open-ended, as there are countless topics that could be addressed. My hope is to find contributors with expertise in particular subfields to help with this phase of the project.

There is one more thing about name Constitutional Perspectives: it is meant as an homage to my grandfather, Charles Black, and in particular to his book Perspectives in Constitutional Law. That book, one of his more obscure, is structured as a kind of slim treatise, a casebook without the cases, and that is also the idea of this project. Of course in the modern age I can simply link to the cases themselves where relevant, but I aspire to discuss everything in a way that should be comprehensible even for those who do not go and read the full opinions. The point, indeed, is not to teach my readers about the cases, but about the Constitution; I am as interested in the story of the great cases as I am in the text of the decisions.

Logo design by Alexandra Gallant-Lee

Animated banner by Victoria Gualtieri

Copyright 2026 Constitutional Innovation Center